How to Lose Weight by Giving Up Diet Soda

84

By Eliminate Cancer

Several years ago, at a family gathering I saw one of the most dramatic transformations that I've ever witnessed. It was a summer party, and many of the family members at the party were people I don't see often. There was a woman I didn't recognize, and I assumed it must be someone's new girlfriend or new acquaintance. She came up to me and greeted me as if she knew me, and it wasn't until she got close, and I heard her voice, that I recognized her. We were related, she was my cousin.

She had lost a lot of weight since the last time I saw her. She was slim, healthy, radiant. I assumed she must have been seriously dieting, but she said no. I asked if she was working out a lot. Again, no; she was still working the night shift and between that and raising children, she had no time. How did she lose so much weight without dieting?

She had replaced her diet soda with water.


What Changed?

I don't remember her reason for switching to water. It could have been that she needed to save money, and buying soda from a vending machine was something she had to give up. It could be that she got a new position that had her working in an area that didn't have a vending machine. Whatever the reason, it was logistical, not for diet.

She had been drinking the diet soda to lose weight, and because she was working night shift, she wanted the caffeine to help her stay awake.

What she discovered, fairly quickly, was that her energy actually INCREASED after switching to water. She was not only losing weight, she wasn't constantly craving snacks, and she had more energy.

When she was trying to diet before, she was not only tired, but feeling hungry all the time, craving junk food, getting headaches, which I think is typical for someone trying to diet. It's hard to get past that hungry feeling in your stomach, and your mind telling you it needs a snack... Somehow, switching to water removed a lot of the frustrating side effects of dieting.

More energy meant she was more active. Even if she couldn't get to the gym, she could put more into her daily tasks, accomplish more, stay on top of things - without counting the calories, it goes without saying that doing more every day is definitely burning more calories every day.


Findings from University of Texas Health Science Center

Comparing the risk for becoming overweight or obese:

Regular Soda Drinkers:

  • 26% for up to 1/2 can each day
  • 30.4% for 1/2 to one can each day
  • 32.8% for 1 to 2 cans each day
  • 47.2% for more than 2 cans each day.

Diet Soda Drinkers:

  • 36.5% for up to 1/2 can each day
  • 37.5% for 1/2 to one can each day
  • 54.5% for 1 to 2 cans each day
  • 57.1% for more than 2 cans each day.

Diet Soda Fools the Brain

I decided to investigate why she would lose so much weight after making one simple change - not even in her diet, just in her choice of beverage.

What I discovered is that in spite of the fact that diet soda has zero calories, there are a few mechanisms that increase your appetite. In fact, the risk of weight gain is HIGHER when you drink diet soda, than if you drink regular soda.

One reason for this is that the sweet taste is telling your brain something sweet is coming, but the body didn't consume any calories, so the brain tells the body to eat something. The reason you don't get this response with regular soda, is that the body is consuming the sugar that the brain expects it to have. This may explain why you have a greater risk of obesity when drinking diet soda. It is better to consume the 150 calories in a can of regular Coke, then to have difficult-to-manage cravings after a Diet Coke - sweet cravings that urge you to grab that packet of cookies later... cookies you justify because you just drank a Diet Coke.

Better yet, drink water. If you drink water, your brain understands this, expects nothing more and is satisfied.


Diet Soda Increases Your Appetite

Animal studies suggest that artificial sweeteners cause weight gain, in theory, because of a faulty insulin response. For example, rats given artificial sweeteners increased their caloric intake, and body weight.

Consuming a product that stimulates your appetite is going to make any diet program extremely frustrating. The biggest struggle when you are on a diet is fighting the feelings of hunger, and the cravings for foods you can't eat.

Simply eliminating diet soda will make any diet program easier to follow, easier to stick with, easier to reach goals. When you begin to see progress, you are motivated to keep going. When you lose weight, you feel better, more energetic. It all feels great.

Diet soda, by increasing your appetite, makes the road to weight-loss and better health an UPHILL battle.


Water: the Ultimate Diet Drink

Not only does water have zero calories, it provides the body with what it needs: water.

People's individual needs for water may vary depending on the weather, and your levels of activity etc., but everyone needs plenty of water every day.

Your body uses water in all of its cells, organs, and tissues to maintain healthy bodily functions and temperature. Water also flushes out toxins. This is critically important, especially for people who are dieting, because as you burn fat, any toxins stored in the fat cells are now circulating in the body. You need a constant intake of water to flush out these toxins before they are stored somewhere else.

There is plenty of research that shows that diet soda increases your risk of obesity, and I have seen myself how simply switching from diet soda to water can make you lose weight.

Why not try it?

If you drink diet soda, try switching to water - lots of water - for one month. I would love to hear about your experience!!


Comments

Joelipoo profile image

Joelipoo Level 4 Commenter 3 months ago

Great hub. Soft drinks are terrible for people in general. I gave up drinking and pop for two straight years, and I felt so much better then. I had been good and not drinking as much, but lately I have had some daily. Water is definitely the way to go. Voted up and useful.

Eliminate Cancer profile image

Eliminate Cancer Hub Author 3 months ago

Thanks - it's great that you remember how good you felt when you gave it up - I always wonder if people are aware of that. That memory will always motivate you to get back there.

I don't think there's a problem indulging from time to time, as a treat.

Sadly, people are drinking diet soda because they think it helps them to lose weight, when it's doing exactly the opposite - which makes them drink more. A product that guarantees failure, that keeps the consumer buying more...

Joelipoo profile image

Joelipoo Level 4 Commenter 3 months ago

It's the perfect marketing tool for the soft drink companies. It gaurentees them continued business. I only started drinking it again because I visited South America and wasn't supposed to drink the water. It was my only option. After giving it up for a few months, you actually lose the desire to have it. I should make the commitment to do it again.

Eliminate Cancer profile image

Eliminate Cancer Hub Author 3 months ago

A bit like how they had to drink beer in the Crusades - LOL!! Eating well while traveling is definitely a challenge :)

Did you write a hub about your trip to South America?? Sounds fascinating!!

moonlake profile image

moonlake Level 7 Commenter 3 months ago

I drink two ex-large cups of diet coke a day. I know it's not good for me but it's a habit like smoking, so hard to stop. Funny I saw your hub because I was just thinking about the diet coke I drink. I had told my husband earlier it's what keeps me alive.

Water is the best way to go. I keep hoping one of these days I will just talk myself into stopping.

Enjoyed your hub.

Eliminate Cancer profile image

Eliminate Cancer Hub Author 3 months ago

Moonlake, maybe switch to regular Coke for a while, take the calories and energy that goes with it and burn them. Might make it easier to transition.

Casey Strouse profile image

Casey Strouse Level 2 Commenter 3 months ago

Tim Ferriss wrote in his book "The Four Hour Body" that diet soda and other beverages that contain artificial sweeteners stimulate weight gain. I try to avoid them even though I have a soft spot for Splenda.

kjrzeek1 profile image

kjrzeek1 Level 4 Commenter 3 days ago

It is amazing how people think drinking diet soda is better for you than regular. Soda is poison, plain and simple. Great hub!

Eliminate Cancer profile image

Eliminate Cancer Hub Author 31 hours ago

I agree kjrzeek1. I try not to judge people by their diet, but I think it's crazy what is sold as 'food' - so much of what is on the grocery store shelves is made up of chemicals, fats, and fillers. People look for labels like 'low fat' or 'diet' trying to eat healthier, but what they really need to look at are the ingredients. Eating simpler foods will make you lose weight.

Submit a Comment
Members and Guests

Sign in or sign up and post using a hubpages account.



    • No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked
    • Comments are not for promoting your Hubs or other sites

    Please wait working